Phoenix, AZ—Okay I’m
jaded. I have investigated so many high
profile cases over the decades and have learned one sad thing about them. Integrity among witnesses, cops and prosecutors
quickly vanishes.
Being a criminal defense
investigator is not like what most people think or understand. While investigating these cases I soon found myself trapped in a world of lies. If I can expose the lies my client often goes
free! Because of bizarre dynamics, this is anything but an easy task.
Let’s begin with a personal
statistic I’ve established about my fellow humans. A full one-third or more of people routinely
lie. As we know most people in fact can’t
seem to tell the truth about something as simple why they’re late for
work.
If this percentage of people
can achieve the same result by lying as telling the truth they will choose to
deceive. It’s best described as a form
of narcissism or self-empowerment.
In high profile cases
deception is the rule, not the exception!
People lie from every possible side of a case skewing justice along the way!
Whether or not the accused is
guilty, those arrested lie most of the time.
They think that lies will help them and they are desperate. Their friends and family members that find
themselves as defense witnesses want to help so they lie too.
For the cops interviewing
those people separately, they can easily expose this deception. Lies told by suspects and their family or
friends will nearly always destroy any chance of escaping even an unjust conviction.
Unfortunately many cops have
a terrible habit of guessing culpability first and then creating, shaping or
forming the evidence to convict those they believe are guilty.
The best example I can cite
here is O.J. Simpson. The case appeared
weak and cops went about to frame a guilty man.
However in the end they got caught and Simpson was freed.
Cops are in the unique
position to remove, move or add physical evidences including DNA to any crime
scene. When they subsequently serve
search warrants more opportunities are presented to place damning evidence
inside the homes, offices or vehicles of the accused.
Motives for this behavior include
seeking professional recognition, fame, or simply being driven to nail the coffin
lids on the people they arrest. Let me
say that the percentages of this happening are so much higher than you would
ever dare imagine.
We all have made ourselves
believe that cops and prosecutors wear the white hats. After all they are the good guys who can
always be trusted never to mislead you, right?
Ego’s, self-image issues and narcissism
are no strangers to cops and prosecutors.
They love the attention they get by publicly demonizing some hapless perceived
miscreant.
In high profile cases this
begins at press conferences where cops and prosecutors pat each other on the
back for the important arrest. Thus the
demonization of the accused begins and the defense is never able to challenge
this with equal time.
By the time the defense
discovers any solid evidence they are subject to gag orders by the judges on
the case! Prosecutors often deliberately
cross the line so that gag orders are issued.
That in effect insures the public will only hear one side of the case!
Once they bring in the TV cameras inside the
courtrooms that suddenly guarantees that lies will become the new truth! Bad behavior and deception go into high
gear!
Savvy cops know how to play
the civilian witnesses by making them feel important. The cops want to hear only the things that
will bolster their cases. So it’s very
easy to ask questions that provide the answers they want to hear the witnesses
repeat!
This often begins with the
first eyewitness identifications. The
witness was either a victim and saw a violent crime committed by a stranger. Their eyes were fixed on weapons, the hands
and shocking deeds of the perpetrator/s.
Soon a cop brings a suspect
to the witness in a police car. The
witness assumes that the cop somehow found the right person and they want to
help the cops.
What happens next is
horrible. The witness will more than likely
identify whomever the cops have brought! After all the witness wants to help
the cops whether they recognize the suspect or not.
Identifications made outside
of a proper line up suck in a big way.
The so-called, one-on-one identification method is excessively
subjective and should be outlawed.
A high percentage of people
will exaggerate or outright lie if they think it will help the police take a
criminal off of our streets. Once the
useful idiot/witness gets praise and recognition he or she will become locked into
the lie forever.
Thankfully the mass
proliferation of surveillance cameras has stopped many false identification
cases cold before they got out of hand.
With the limelight of TV
cameras, and recognition from the likes of TV commentators such as Nancy Grace witnesses
abandon the truth and instead gravitate to what’s seems popular at the moment.
It’s exactly like the intuitive
Dr. Josef Goebbels infamously said, “If you tell a lie often enough, it becomes the
truth.” The media can be counted on to
repeat each and every lie until they are set in stone!
When you allow a murder trial
like the Jodi Arias case to become a media circus only bad things will happen.
Today with the Internet and
our instant communication keeping a jury away from sensational influence
outside of the courtroom is impossible.
Guilt or innocence is
established by a lot of things in America.
Unfortunately too often the truth does not really matter.
This all takes me to my
personal motto about the criminal justice system, “If justice happens it’s
usually by accident and for all the wrong reasons.”
Soon a cop brings a suspect to the witness in a police car. The witness assumes that the cop somehow found the right person and they want to help the cops.
ReplyDeleteA prime example of this is the case in Florida, "Murder on a Sunday Morning". If you never heard of it, look it up. Brenton Butler. Thank goodness he was freed.
Soon a cop brings a suspect to the witness in a police car. The witness assumes that the cop somehow found the right person and they want to help the cops.
ReplyDeleteA prime example of this is the case in Florida, "Murder on a Sunday Morning". If you never heard of it, look it up. Brenton Butler. Thank goodness he was freed.
Kim Wilde, I lived with the deception of lying for over 40 years and you are so correct about how often people lie ! We lie about anything and everything ! I accepted JESUS as my personal Savior and through HIS Grace no longer have to lie about anything. It is so refreshing to be able to tell the truth about everything always! Ask JESUS to forgive you of your sins and to cleanse your heart and HE will not only forgive you, but HE will set you free !
ReplyDeleteWhat a great post, Paul!
ReplyDeleteI'm sure the Ministry of Truth will be in touch... They don't like lies like "2+2=4" and "blue is blue" and what you said. They prefer, "black is white; day is night."
There are a lot of folks that live in Lala Land, trusting the justice system (sic) to be ... well ... just. Once in a while, it is. This mostly happens when you keep yourself far, far away from it. ...makes you want to dig a hole and crawl in, or be a character in a true-life The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress... or something.
Lately, we see multitudes of terrible cases of abuse, overreach and falsification by cops, but also by all elements of the system…
We see criminal conspiracy among even judges. See Attorney Richard Fine’s story (L.A. County, CA, 2010) of illegal solitary coercive confinement here: http://www.fulldisclosure.net/2010/12/richard-fine-wins-his-freedom-exclusive-full-disclosure-interview/#14157986447281&38440 The judge that did that should be on trial for capital obstruction of justice—“capital” because he’s a violent, felonious judge, not just some “unknowing” violent felon.
It doesn't take much of a scratch to scratch and sniff U.S. "administration of justice" and be overwhelmed by the stench of the injustice. But most people, like abused children too fearful to admit that their parents are monsters—it's terrifying (resultant of “official” terrorism?—THAT is where the “War on Terror” should be directed. But … by whom?) to live in a country where the wheels of justice (sic) grind the bones of the innocent.
People have to be willing to see what is right in front of them, quit denying, recognize the monstrosity, and by sheer will of noncompliance, break it. It won’t go quietly into the night, but when it strikes in that Stalin-level murderousness that is completely predictable, that way everyone knows who’s the aggressor.
What amazes me out west in LA: the extent of evidence amplification and the suborning of jailhouse informant perjury. They pull some mutt out of county lockup and tell him what to say; then they turn one ounce into a pound--- and get away with it easily. Add to that the threat to take children away from parents, and you have institutionalized injustice.
ReplyDeleteWhat amazes me out west in LA: the extent of evidence amplification and the suborning of jailhouse informant perjury. They pull some mutt out of county lockup and tell him what to say; then they turn one ounce into a pound--- and get away with it easily. Add to that the threat to take children away from parents, and you have institutionalized injustice.
ReplyDeleteGreetings
ReplyDeleteYou wrote:
"We all have made ourselves believe that cops and prosecutors wear the white hats. After all they are the good guys who can always be trusted never to mislead you, right? "
That is a flat-out lie. I don't believe that these skanks wear white hats. Nor do you, right?
So why, in an essay about lying, do you lie?
Since police departments are merely standing civilian armies, abolish them and leave it up to citizens to provide their own security as their own expense and liability. If this were the case, victimless crimes would remain unprosecuted and people who break into private homes would wind up in morgues.
ReplyDeletePolice officers are taught subterfuge in the same way that medical doctors are not taught nutrition.
ReplyDeleteIf Americans really cared about justice, they'd be signing up for common law grand juries in droves.
They are not taught in the sense of classroom instruction. It's more like monkey see, monkey do.
ReplyDeleteIt's about win at all cost, not seek justice.
I just found and read your essay. Good stuff, every word of it.
ReplyDelete